Yes. Consolidating two mortgages into one is a refinance: a new first mortgage large enough to pay out both, leaving you with a single payment at a single rate.
Whether it saves money depends on three numbers – your combined loan-to-value, the penalty on breaking your first, and the rate you can get today.
How it works
The new lender registers a first charge, pays out the existing first and second mortgages, and discharges both. You are left with one mortgage, one payment, one renewal date.
Second mortgages typically carry rates well above first mortgages – often several points higher, and considerably more with a private lender. Folding a second into a first at first-mortgage pricing is where the savings come from.
The 80% limit
A refinance in Canada is capped at 80% of the property’s appraised value. This is the constraint that decides most of these files.
On a $900,000 home: – Maximum new mortgage: $720,000 – If your first is $520,000 and your second is $150,000, the combined $670,000 fits comfortably – If your first is $600,000 and your second is $180,000, the combined $780,000 does not fit – you would need to bring $60,000 to closing
Mortgage insurance is not available on a refinance, so there is no route above 80%. If the numbers do not fit, consolidation is not available at a prime lender.
The appraisal decides this, not your estimate of what the house is worth. Order it early.
When consolidating makes sense
Your second mortgage is expensive. A private second at 10–12% against a first at 4.5% is the clearest case. Rolling $150,000 from 11% into 4.5% saves roughly $9,750 a year in interest.
The second is maturing. Private seconds are usually one-year terms and must be renewed or repaid. Renewal fees recur annually and add up.
You want one payment and one renewal date. Administrative, but real – two mortgages means two renewals, two sets of terms, and two chances to be caught out.
Your first is at or near renewal. No penalty, so the calculation is purely rate versus rate.
If combining looks right for you, our mortgage refinancing service in Toronto compares the new single rate with what you pay now on both mortgages, including penalties and fees.
When it does not
The penalty is too large. If you are two years into a five-year fixed at a big bank, the interest rate differential can be $10,000 to $20,000. Against a second mortgage of $60,000 at 9%, the penalty can exceed several years of the interest you would save.
You would lose a very low rate. A first mortgage at 2.5% from 2021 is worth keeping. Consolidating it into today’s rates raises the cost on the entire balance, not just the second-mortgage portion.
Run this arithmetic carefully: interest saved on the second, minus the increase in cost on the first, minus the penalty. If that is negative, keep them separate.
You exceed 80%. No prime lender will do it.
The second is short-term and nearly repaid. Paying it out from savings is simpler and cheaper.
The alternatives
Refinance the first, use the proceeds to pay out the second. Mechanically the same thing, and the usual approach.
Blend and extend. Some lenders will blend your existing rate with today’s rate on additional funds, avoiding the penalty entirely. Only your current lender can offer this, and the blended rate is rarely the best available – but with a large penalty it is often the cheapest overall.
Replace the second with a HELOC. Better rate than a private second, no penalty on the first, and interest only on what you draw. Subject to the same 80% combined limit.
Do nothing. If the second is small, cheap and nearly repaid, leave it.
See also second mortgage vs. refinance for when keeping a second mortgage beats refinancing.
Costs
| Item | Typical |
|---|---|
| Appraisal | $300 – $600 |
| Legal fees | $1,000 – $2,000 |
| Discharge of the second | $200 – $400 |
| Prepayment penalty on the first | 3 months’ interest, or the IRD |
| Broker fee | Usually none on prime; disclosed if applicable |
Excluding any penalty, expect $1,500 to $3,000.
Frequently asked questions
Can I merge two mortgages into one? Yes, through a refinance – a new first mortgage large enough to pay out both, leaving one payment and one renewal date. The total must stay within 80% of the appraised value.
How do I get rid of a second mortgage? Pay it out from savings, refinance the first to cover it, replace it with a HELOC at a better rate, or use blend-and-extend with your existing lender to avoid a penalty. Which is cheapest depends on your penalty and how long is left on your term.
Is a second mortgage a good idea? As a short-term tool, sometimes – to avoid breaking a very low first mortgage, to bridge a gap, or to consolidate expensive debt. As a long-term arrangement it is expensive, since second-mortgage rates run well above first-mortgage rates and private seconds carry annual renewal fees.
Can a second mortgage be refinanced? Yes, either on its own with a new second-mortgage lender, or by folding it into a new first mortgage.
What is a blended mortgage? Your lender averages your existing rate with today’s rate on new funds, producing a single blended rate – and no prepayment penalty, because you are not breaking the mortgage. Only your current lender can offer it.
Is a blended mortgage a good idea? When your penalty is large, often yes. The blended rate is rarely the best available in the market, but avoiding a five-figure penalty usually outweighs a small rate premium. Run both numbers before deciding.
What is the “2-2-2 rule” for mortgages? An American rule of thumb – two years in the same job, two years in the same industry, two months of reserves. It has no Canadian equivalent. Canadian lenders look at credit score, debt service ratios, down payment source, and how documentable your income is.
Can I consolidate credit cards and car loans at the same time? Yes, within the 80% limit, and that is often the larger saving. Moving $60,000 of credit card debt at 20% into a mortgage at 4.5% saves roughly $9,300 a year in interest.
Get the arithmetic run properly
The decision comes down to comparing the penalty against the interest saved, and lenders will not do that calculation for you.
Turkin Mortgage works with over 35 lenders – prime, alternative and private. We will get the exact penalty figure from your current lender, run consolidation against blend-and-extend against leaving it alone, and tell you which is cheapest.
Sometimes the answer is to do nothing. We will say so.
No cost, no obligation, no credit check to start.
General information as of August 2026. Confirm penalty amounts with your current lender before deciding.